Category Archives: Cognitive Archaeology

The Primal Inference

Joseph Campbell, Carl Jung and other scholars have explored in detail the great myths and legends from cultures around the world, and uncovered universal structures of human thought. But before these myths, before the development of symbolic human thought, there was a more literal age – the pre-pagan era. Paleoanthropologists have made a parallel distinction by reclassifying the humans who possessed abstract thought and demonstrated “modern” behavior by doubling up on the sapience. Early humans are called simply Homo sapiens, but the modern ones are referred to as Homo sapiens sapiens. It is as if they are at least twice as sapient.

The pre-pagans were pure pragmatists. Everything they did was for the practical purpose of staying alive. Perhaps that’s why the early cave paintings were variations of the theme of “How to kill an Animal.” So instead of fancy mythologies filling their heads, the pre-pagans simply had the basic thought, “Kill animal.” This thought is represented in this cave painting of a pre-pagan archer killing a beast.

Chaturbhujnath Nala small

.

Anybody who has taken an introduction to logic course will recognize this as a pictorial representation of a basic logical conditional or inference.  (If P, then Q, or P implies Q.  The bow clearly corresponds to the “P” in the inference, the arrow to the arrow, and the animal with a tail to the “Q.”

p arrow q 2

 

In Search of the Paleolithic Mind

The Sapient Paradox

The greatest mystery of mankind is our true identity. Who are we? This is the ultimate question of all philosophy, all religion and even some of science. A major clue resides in the great paradox of homo sapiens: We have been genetically distinct as a species for as much as 200,000 years, but for most of that time we didn’t act especially human – at least not like we do today. The archaeological record shows no sign of creativity until about 70,000 years ago. That’s the date of a rock carved with striations that don’t appear practical – mere decoration. This celebrated  rock was found in a cave on the South African Coast. And then there were cave paintings around 40,000 years ago or so. But it wasn’t until the development of agriculture around 10,000 years ago that we can look back and say these people acted like we would. The creation of large cities, metallurgy and writing all indicate that modern humans had arrived at last.

The sapient paradox is this 190,000 year lag, more of less, between the arrival of genetically modern homo sapiens and behaviorally modern homo sapiens. Paleoanthropologists mark this distinction by referring to the behaviorally modern humans as homo sapiens sapiens.